Wednesday, December 7, 2011

A Christmas Carol - 1999

Ok adaptation of this classic tale that closely followed the basic Dickens plot, but the modernized dialog was definitely a distraction. Also, the contrast between the bleak emotions in the first part of the story and the Christmas cheer at the end were not as defined as earlier films which took some of the impact out of the change in Scrooge and was a weakness in this version. Ok performance by Patrick Stewart as Scrooge, though, that demonstrates his talent as an actor. Only so-so performances by the supporting cast especially the important role of Bob Cratchit who seemed too wooden, and Tiny Tim who definitely seemed a little too healthy. This film also included more special effects than earlier productions which often seemed out of place, but not annoyingly so (with the exception of Christmas Past and his glowing 1960’s “sci-fi” eyes!) Ok filming but the sets and costuming must have had a small budget and weren’t up to par with earlier films. Still, as a fan of this story in all its variations (even the cheesy ones) this is an enjoyable addition to the “Christmas Carol” family. ***

Monday, December 5, 2011

A Christmas Carol - 1951

Excellent adaptation of this classic story. This well known version has a great script that moves smoothly and even neatly fills in a few of the gaps in the Dickens story. Exceptional performances by both Alastair Sim as Scrooge, as well as a superb supporting cast, that gave great emotional depth to the changes in Scrooge. Excellent B&W filming that succeeded in enhancing the various emotional levels created in this film. Wonderful detail in both the sets and costuming. As a fan of “Christmas Carol” in all its various adaptations (including the cheesy ones), the holidays are not complete without viewing this particular one! Definitely one of my top two favorites! *****

A Christmas Carol - 1984

Exceptional adaptation of this classic story. Great script that moves smoothly with outstanding performances by George C. Scott as Scrooge as well as a superb supporting cast. The emotional levels of this story are wonderfully portrayed. Excellent filming and costuming. This version also has my favorite “Christmas Carol” endings with great final scenes between both Scrooge and Bob Cratchit (Bob's amazed shock in this version is superb) and Scrooge with his nephew, Fred, and his wife. As a fan of “Christmas Carol” in all its various adaptations (including the cheesy ones), the holidays are not complete without viewing this particular one! Definitely one of my top two favorites! *****