This film is the first talking adaptation of this classic novel. At only an hour, it would be impossible to show a very detailed version of this story. Jane’s early life is compressed into 2 or 3 scenes and the rest of her life doesn’t fare much better. This isn’t unusual, though, considering the era this was filmed. Hollywood approached movies differently in the 30's and it is evident in this film. Only the barest outline of the actual story has been kept. The acting is only so-so but the main complaint comes from character changes rather than the acting itself. Rochester is a far cry from the brooding character in the book and Jane has very little personality at all. The print I watched was also in poor condition but considering its age of 75+ years it is not surprising. Even so, as one of the many cinematic versions of this well loved novel, it is worth your time. **
No comments:
Post a Comment